Hold a 'Hamilton' streaming party with these fun and easy recipes

Hamilton Party1
Schuyler Sister cakes can be made easily with Barbies you already own, or cheap dolls you can find at a dollar store. David Samson/The Forum

FARGO — While many Americans are counting down to the fun of July 4th, some Broadway musical fans are looking even more forward to July 3rd. That’s the date that Tony Award-winning, mega smash “Hamilton” will begin streaming on Disney+.

It is rumored that Disney paid $75 million for the worldwide rights to the live recording, filmed over three nights with the show’s original cast. Disney originally planned to release the filmed version of “Hamilton” in theaters in the fall of 2021, but with Broadway shutting down because of the coronavirus pandemic, it was moved up to this summer for home-viewing.

Creator Lin-Manuel Miranda said in a statement: "I'm so grateful to Disney and Disney+ for re-imagining and moving up our release to July 4th weekend of this year, in light of the world turning upside down. I'm so grateful to all the fans who asked for this, and I'm so glad that we're able to make it happen. I'm so proud of this show. I can't wait for you to see it."


Hamilton creator Lin-Manuel is grateful to Disney for releasing his production earlier than planned to entertain Americans stuck at home during the pandemic. Photo: flickr

For all of you people looking forward to watching it, why not make a night of it and throw a “Hamilton party?”

We’ve compiled a few recipes we first brought to you in 2016 when “Hamilton” first hit, but we’ve added a few more that will help you celebrate in style with the founding fathers.

Each recipe is a nod to Hamilton’s life or the characters or songs in the show. See all the recipes at the bottom.

The first recipe honors Hamilton’s childhood in the British West Indies where the young boy, son of a single mom, survived on salted fish and pork. (Don’t worry, this recipe is more cruise ship fabulous than Caribbean scraps.)


By the time he came to America and started hobnobbing with the young nation’s elite, Hamilton is said to have loved fine beef. In the book “Dinner at Mr. Jefferson’s,” author Charles Cerami says while dining with Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, Hamilton “praised extravagantly” the boeuf a la mode, or French beef stew. But beef stew seems a bit heavy for mid-summer, so why not make some Aaron Burr-gers. Get it? No need for a special recipe here, just make your favorite burger. I’ll throw in a recipe below of one of my favorites, the John Wheeler (yes, that John Wheeler of WDAY) burger. I’m sure if A-Ham were alive today, he’d put on his Bermuda shorts, crack open a Bud Light and throw them on the grill himself. After all, he was “young, scrappy and hungry,” right?

Born into obscurity in the British West Indies, Alexander Hamilton made his reputation during the Revolutionary War and became one of America's most influential Founding Fathers.

And speaking of A. Ham, if you want to go all out for the theme, throw together some “A. Ham" Dill Pickle Wraps. This is one of my favorite go-to appetizers, although I do prefer it with corned beef instead of ham. But last I checked, corned beef did not have its own musical on Broadway. Wait, does “Spamalot” count?

We need a cocktail to toast Hamilton and the country he helped build. I found a site called GoodFoodStories that had a bunch of them. “My Shot: An Alexander Hamilton Cocktail” celebrates Hamilton’s life by combining Caribbean rum with Virginia whiskey (and a few other ingredients). If you want to really go nuts with “Hamilton” cocktails, the site also features “Work! A Schuyler Sister’s Cocktail” and “Aaron Burr, Sir: A Milk Punch Cocktail.”

By the way, if you’re wondering where I got the Alexander Hamilton shot glass pictured, it’s from a site called Fish’s Eddy. History buffs won’t be surprised that they also sell an Aaron Burr shot glass.

You need to finish your meal with something sweet. You have a choice. The first recipe is inspired by that old TV commercial that popularized the Aaron Burr/Alexander Hamilton duel long before the musical did. It features a man with a mouth full of peanut butter unable to answer a trivia question from a radio contest. Just watch.


Because of that, it seems fitting to make peanut butter milkshakes. There’s some milk in them, so it won’t stick to the roof of your mouth in case a radio station trivia contest calls.

If you really want to “work”, try making Schuyler Sisters Cakes using any of the several easy Barbie Doll cakes you can find online.

Hamilton Streaming Party Recipes

This Carribean Inspired cod salad is a light and fresh start to a summer meal. Forum file photo

“Forgotten Spot in the Caribbean” Salted Cod Salad

Serves: 4


1 pound cod, poached, chilled then flaked
½ red bell pepper, chopped
½ small red onion, chopped
Juice of 1 lime
2 tablespoons avocado or olive oil
½ teaspoon sea salt (or less, if preferred)
Handful fresh cilantro or parsley, chopped
1 avocado, chopped or sliced
1 cup cooked quinoa (optional)


Mix all ingredients. Best if refrigerated for 1 hour before serving.
Caribbean-Inspired Salted Cod Salad Recipe from

Use your favorite recipe to make "Aaron Burr-gers" for your Hamilton party. Photo: iStock

“Aaron Burr-gers”

Serves: 4

Make your favorite burger if you don’t have one, try one of my favorites, John Wheeler Burgers. We all know John Wheeler as that man who delivers the forecast of the good, the bad and the downright frigid. But WDAY-TV’s chief meteorologist also makes some of the world’s greatest hamburgers.


1 pound 80 percent lean ground beef (leaner beef doesn’t work as well)
1 teaspoon black pepper
⅛ teaspoon cayenne pepper
¼-½ teaspoon onion powder
8 crushed Ritz crackers
1 egg
4-5 shakes of Worcestershire sauce (a few tablespoons)
1 generous shake of A-1 Steak Sauce
A dash of Tiger Sauce
4 tablespoons melted butter or margarine
½ cup or so of burgundy wine (any inexpensive red wine works well)


Mix all ingredients (except butter and wine) well. Shape into four patties (Recipe is easily doubled or tripled). Mix melted butter and wine together in a small bowl. Place burgers on a hot grill, and baste with butter/wine mixture. Close lid. When it’s time to turn the burgers, baste the other side. Cook until done.

Recipe from ‘Paper to Palate’ cookbook, Forum Communications

"A Ham" rollups are an easy and delicious appetizer. Photo: Flickr

“A.Ham” Dill Pickle Wraps

Serves: 10


5 slices of ham
6 ounces softened cream cheese
10 baby dill pickles


Spread cream cheese on slices of ham. In each slice of ham place a pickle and roll up into a cylinder. Press together so cream cheese acts like a glue. Put on plate and chill for at least an hour. Using a sharp knife, slice cylinders into several small pieces. Serve.

A proper Alexander Hamilton cocktail might include rum from the Carribbean where he was raised mixed with American whisky. Forum file photo

“My Shot” - An Alexander Hamilton Cocktail

Serves: 2


2 tablespoons (1 fluid ounce) Laird’s Applejack
2 tablespoons (1 fluid ounce) Virginia whiskey, such as Virginia Distillery’s Highland Malt Whisky
1 tablespoon (½ fluid ounce) spiced Caribbean rum, such as Brinley Gold Shipwreck
1 tablespoon (½ fluid ounce) St. Elizabeth allspice dram
1/3 to ½ cup (about 3 fluid ounces) dry cider


Stir the Applejack, whiskey, rum and allspice dram together in a mixing glass. Divide the liquor evenly between 2 3-ounce glasses. Top each cocktail with 1 to 1½ ounces cider. Raise a glass and sip; do not throw away your shot.
Recipe from

A peanut butter milkshake is a nice change from chocolate and vanilla. Photo courtesy: Jif

Peanut Butter "Got Milk"shakes

Serves: 2

1 cup cold milk
1/4 cup Creamy Peanut Butter
1 cup vanilla ice cream
Whipped cream
Chopped roasted peanuts

Place milk and peanut butter in a blender. Cover and process until smooth. Add ice cream. Cover and process until smooth. Pour into serving glasses. Top with whipped cream and peanuts, if desired.
Recipe from: Jif

Hamilton Party1
Schuyler Sister cakes can be made easily with Barbies you already own, or cheap dolls you can find at a dollar store. David Samson/The Forum

“Work!” Schuyler Sisters Cake

(Make three cakes to represent all three sisters. Each cake serves: 16


Vegetable shortening and flour for greasing bowl
3 pkgs (15.25-16.5 oz or 510 g) yellow or devil’s food or cake mix (plus ingredients to make cake)
3 tubs prepared white frosting
Food coloring (The sisters' dresses are blue, pink and light yellow)
Barbie-like doll (I used three dolls I found at a dollar store)
3- 2 quart Pyrex or Pampered Chef Glass Mixing Bowls

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C). Grease a 2-quart ovenproof Pyrex glass mixing bowls (or Pampered Chef Classic Batter Bowls) with shortening and dust with flour. Prepare cakes as directed on box. Pour batter into prepared bowls. Bake 45 to 50 minutes or until cake tester inserted into center comes out clean. Cool 15 minutes.Invert on cake plate with widest part of cakes on the bottom. Cool 3 hours before decorating. Frost the cakes with pink, blue or yellow icing. Prepare the dolls. I found the dolls were too tall to make the cake look like a skirt, so I took the legs off the dolls. Then inserted the legless dolls into center of each cake. Add other details to make the dresses as fancy as you like.

Recipe inspired by All Recipes and Pampered Chef

Tracy Briggs is an Emmy-nominated News, Lifestyle and History reporter with Forum Communications with more than 35 years of experience, in broadcast, print and digital journalism.
What To Read Next
Buddy Holly tribute, comedian Chad Daniels and the return of the Red River Market offer quieter options.
The Minneapolis show is the 20th stop of the 41-show tour of her "Renaissance World Tour," bringing a live taste of her latest album to 40 cities in North America and Europe.
Hit "Lollipop" 39th biggest song of the 2000s.
The writer and former radio host last performed in the area in 2017 at Concordia.