ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Oscars: Social buzz was poor predictor of winners compared with gambling sites

LOS ANGELES - It's the difference between just mouthing off and putting your money where your mouth is. Leading up to Sunday night's 87th Annual Academy Awards, Facebook and Twitter - along with third-party social analysis researchers Adobe, Hoot...

Oscars
Director Alejandro Inarritu accepts the Oscar for best picture for his film "Birdman or (The Unexpected Virture of Ignorance)"during the 87th Academy Awards in Hollywood, California February 22, 2015. REUTERS

LOS ANGELES - It's the difference between just mouthing off and putting your money where your mouth is.

Leading up to Sunday night's 87th Annual Academy Awards, Facebook and Twitter - along with third-party social analysis researchers Adobe, Hootsuite and Way to Blue - issued predictions of Oscar winners based on digital buzz.

The results? Out of their 29 predictions for the six major categories (Twitter didn't have a pick for best director), the forecasts got only 13 correct.

By contrast, betting sites, based on their pre-Oscars odds, were far more reliable. PredictWise, which aggregates info from U.K.-based Betfair, Hollywood Stock Exchange and other "prediction markets," correctly predicted 20 of 24 total Oscars winners, including for the major categories. For example, PredictWise as of Sunday at 2 p.m. gave "Birdman" a certainty rating of winning best picture of 67 percent and assigned "Birdman" helmer Alejandro G. Inarritu a 57 percent edge over "Boyhood's" Richard Linklater at 43 percent for best director.

Among the social researchers, only Adobe and Way to Blue predicted "Birdman" would win best picture, while none had forecast Inarritu taking home the best director statue for the film. The only category they all got right was Julianne Moore's best actress win for "Still Alice" - evidently the safest bet of the night.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why does this matter? After all, Facebook, Twitter and the others offered disclaimers of one kind or another noting that they couldn't really predict the outcomes with certainty.

The Oscars exercise underscores an important point: The wisdom of crowds is only as good as the crowd you're listening to. It's worth noting that Way to Blue, a British PR and consulting firm, got five out of six right; it used a relatively small selection of comments (less than 100,000) culled from Twitter, blog and news sites. Some social-media hypesters would have you believe that Internet chatter, analyzed in aggregate, can produce all kinds of interesting and actionable insights for content owners and marketers alike. But there's an old computer-science maxim that applies here: garbage in, garbage out.

Here's what social companies and third-party analytics firms had predicted prior to Sunday's Oscars, with the correct picks designated in bold.

Facebook

Best Picture - "American Sniper"

Best Actor - Bradley Cooper

Best Actress - Julianne Moore

Best Supporting Actor - J.K. Simmons

ADVERTISEMENT

Best Supporting Actress - Meryl Streep

Best Director - Richard Linklater

Twitter

Best Picture - "Selma"

Best Actor Benedict Cumberbatch

Best Actress - Julianne Moore

Best Supporting Actor - Mark Ruffalo

Best Supporting Actress - Meryl Streep

ADVERTISEMENT

Best Director - N.A.

Adobe*

Best Picture - "Birdman"

Best Actor - Bradley Cooper

Best Actress - Julianne Moore

Best Supporting Actor - J.K. Simmons

Best Supporting Actress - Meryl Streep

Best Director - Wes Anderson

Hootsuite**

Best Picture - "The Theory of Everything"

Best Actor - Eddie Redmayne

Best Actress - Julianne Moore

Best Supporting Actor - Mark Ruffalo

Best Supporting Actress - Laura Dern

Best Director - Wes Anderson

Way to Blue***

Best Picture - "Birdman"

Best Actor - Eddie Redmayne

Best Actress - Julianne Moore

Best Supporting Actor - J.K. Simmons

Best Supporting Actress - Patricia Arquette

Best Director - Richard Linklater

* Based on 3 million social mentions across Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and others from Jan. 15-Feb. 16. ** Based on data from more than 20 social-media platforms including Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Google+. *** Based on data from Toronto-based Sysomos for comments Twitter, news, blogs and forums from Feb. 12-18.

Related Topics: MOVIES
What To Read Next
The Minneapolis-based chef's restaurant Owamni won the 2022 James Beard Award for Best New Restaurant.
Buddy Holly tribute, comedian Chad Daniels and the return of the Red River Market offer quieter options.
The Minneapolis show is the 20th stop of the 41-show tour of her "Renaissance World Tour," bringing a live taste of her latest album to 40 cities in North America and Europe.
Hit "Lollipop" 39th biggest song of the 2000s.