Two Minnesota churches vote to exit ELCA

Two churches in the Northwestern Minnesota Synod have voted in favor of leaving the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, while a congregation near Pelican Rapids recently canceled a Dec. 6 vote on its own status with the ELCA.

Two churches in the Northwestern Minnesota Synod have voted in favor of leaving the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, while a congregation near Pelican Rapids recently canceled a Dec. 6 vote on its own status with the ELCA.

In Erskine, 80 percent of congregants at Rodnes Lutheran Church voted on Oct. 18 to leave the ELCA, the Rev. Peter Satren said.

And congregants at Bethlehem/West Elbow Lake Lutheran Church, in Elbow Lake, voted 42 to 11 in September to break from the denomination, congregation President Brian Boeddeker said.

That congregation, however, will retake its vote. After the vote, there was discussion about whether proper notice had been given. Boeddeker said to make sure all are content with the handling of the vote and to make sure it's done properly, they'll hold the vote again. He said he believes that vote will be Dec. 13.

A two-thirds majority is required for such votes to carry. To leave the ELCA, the congregations must also take a second vote with two-thirds majority at least 90 days after the initial vote.


According to 2008 numbers on the ELCA Web site, Rodness had 68 baptized members and Bethlehem/West Elbow Lake had 156. There are 270 congregations in the Northwestern Minnesota Synod.

The actions come on the heels of the ELCA's Churchwide Assembly in August when the denomination moved to allow gays in committed relationships to serve in the clergy. The assembly also approved a social statement that some critics have seen as betraying biblical teaching against same-gender sex.

But Boeddeker does not see the Elbow Lake congregation's vote as a reaction to the assembly's actions related to gays.

"It had nothing to do with that," he said.

"Basically ... we just feel the ELCA doesn't represent our congregation any more as far as the way we feel," he said. "They're getting away from teaching the Scriptures the way they were written."

As for the Erskine congregation, Satren said the "tipping point was the homosexual issue at the assembly. But the argument that people (in his congregation) made was that the ELCA has forsaken the truth of Scripture."

Rodnes' second vote is set for May.

"We're grieved to hear of their desire to leave," Northwestern Minnesota Synod Bishop Larry Wohlrabe said of the two congregations. "We are a family. ... It's akin to a family member saying I won't be coming to Thanksgiving, or I have to leave this family."


Meanwhile, the congregation president of North Immanuel Lutheran church near Pelican Rapids posted a notice this week that that church's Dec. 6 vote on leaving the ELCA had been canceled, the Rev. Curtis Tilleraas said.

Tilleraas said the now-canceled vote was scheduled in response to the assembly votes on sexuality. But he added that the issue is "more a question of biblical authority and the role of biblical authority in the church than it is, for us, about gays and lesbians."

He also said there is a range of opinion on the ELCA's decisions in his congregation, from those who are happy to those who are displeased.

And Tilleraas said the vote wasn't to be simply a vote to leave, but rather a vote on whether to leave or stay.

Tilleraas said he does not know if the vote will be rescheduled. He directed questions regarding why the vote was canceled to congregational President Chris Thysell, saying he was not at liberty to talk about that. Thysell did not immediately return calls for comment.

The congregation, which 2008 ELCA numbers put at 206 baptized members, is scheduled to host Bishop Wohlrabe on Dec. 1 for an informational meeting.

As for the Eastern North Dakota Synod, Bishop Bill Rindy was not aware of any votes to leave the ELCA by congregations on his side of the river. And he said he wasn't aware of any that were scheduled.

Readers can reach Forum reporter Shane Mercer at (701) 451-5734

Related Topics: FAITH
What To Read Next
"It’s easy to make assumptions about a person based on their outfit or their day job," Coming Home columnist Jessie Veeder writes. "I mean, my dad used to work in a bank and he also broke horses and played in a bar band at night."
This week, gardening columnist Don Kinzler fields questions on hibiscus plants, beating apple trees and how long grass seeds will last.
Columnist Carol Bradley Bursack explains the differences between Alzheimer's, dementia and other common forms of dementia.
If it plays well in Winnipeg, it’ll be a hit in Fargo, and all points within planting distance.