Fargo officers who fatally shot Mapleton man during mental health crisis didn't violate policy, chief says

Fargo Police Chief Zibolski will discuss the internal investigation in the Andrew Martinez shooting on Thursday.

officers-shooting (2).png
From left, Sgt. Travis Moser, Detective Josh Heller, Investigator Jordan Korte and Detective Ryan Jasper.
Fargo Police Department
We are part of The Trust Project.

FARGO — Four Fargo police officers did not violate agency policy when they fatally shot a Mapleton man during a mental health crisis , according to Fargo Police Chief David Zibolski.

Zibolski confirmed an internal investigation cleared Sgt. Travis Moser, Detective Josh Heller, Detective Ryan Jasper and Investigator Jordan Korte of wrongdoing in connection to the Aug. 1 death of 35-year-old Andrew Martinez, city spokeswoman Katie Ettish said. The four have returned to active duty, according to city officials.

The chief plans to discuss the findings of that investigation at the Thursday, Oct. 27, Police Advisory and Oversight Board meeting.

Andrew Martinez.jpeg
Andrew Martinez.
Submitted photo

“Chief Zibolski will answer questions related to this during that time,” Ettish said in an email to The Forum. Requests made Tuesday for an interview with Zibolski and a copy of the report detailing the findings of the internal probe were not fulfilled by publishing time.

The announcement comes almost two months after the four officers fired more than 20 rounds from AR-15 rifles at Martinez in his house.


North Dakota Attorney General Drew Wrigley determined the four officers were justified in shooting Martinez because the man pointed an AR-15 rifle at police. Martinez was white and Hispanic. The four officers are white.

The Cass County Sheriff’s Office initially responded around 10:30 a.m. Aug. 1 to Mapleton, a town about 10 miles west of Fargo, for a report of shots fired. Neighbors said Martinez appeared to be intoxicated and had a handgun, according to authorities.

Video played during a mid-September press conference showed deputies responding as two more shots were fired. Sheriff Jesse Jahner set up a perimeter around Martinez’s house as he asked for other agencies to offer mutual aid.

Jahner did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday.

The Fargo and West Fargo police departments responded as a negotiator with the sheriff’s office tried to convince Martinez to come outside peacefully, Jahner said. In what were described as “up and down” talks, the sheriff said Martinez would, at times, speak with law enforcement then become agitated with the situation.

The Fargo Human Rights Commission was "out of order" in its attempts to formulate a proposal to find an outside firm to look into the fatal shootings of Shane Netterville and Andrew Martinez. Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Director Terry Hogan recommended the human rights commission allow the police board to take up the issue.

Police discovered Martinez was a suspect in criminal activity that contributed to his mental health crisis, they said. Jahner said Marsy’s Law bars him from discussing the details of that criminal activity.

After an hourslong standoff, Martinez told law enforcement he was coming out with a gun, Jahner said. The negotiator repeatedly told Martinez to come out of the house unarmed.

Officers heard a sound similar to a gun being racked before Martinez appeared behind a glass door with a rifle pointed in the air, Wrigley told reporters. Martinez then lowered his gun and pointed it at officers, Jahner said.


Video shows a long object coming out the door.

That’s when law enforcement opened fire. Martinez died at the scene.

Moser, Heller, Jasper and Korte are part of the metro area street crimes unit. The unit typically investigates gang-related crimes, goes after fugitives and helps local agencies investigate serious or recurring criminal incidents.

Martinez hadn’t committed a criminal offense since 2009, when he was arrested for driving under the influence. The metro area street crimes unit was available to respond to the incident when the sheriff’s office called for backup, Jahner said.

Martinez fought depression, his family said in a statement that called on law enforcement to reevaluate how it responds to a mental health crisis. The family said it was saddened that Wrigley decided the officers were justified in the shooting.

“We recognize and appreciate the effort made to peacefully resolve the terrible situation that day, but knowing that Andrew was in crisis and not in his right mind, we wish that more would have been done to prevent this tragic outcome,” the family said in the statement. “It’s hard for us to understand how a call for help to save his life during one of his lowest moments ultimately ended his life.”

The family’s attorney, Tim O’Keeffe, did not immediately respond to a request for comment for this story.

April Baumgarten joined The Forum in February 2019 as an investigative reporter. She grew up on a ranch 10 miles southeast of Belfield, N.D., where her family raises Hereford cattle. She double majored in communications and history/political science at the University of Jamestown, N.D.
What To Read Next
Xylazine has been linked to a rising number of fatal overdoses across the U.S., according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse.
People in need of food in North Dakota and Clay County, Minnesota, increased 14% in 2022, and donations were down 25% for Great Plains Food Bank.
“We have heard from our citizens throughout this process,” Commissioner Denise Kolpack said. “I certainly am taking their input to heart on this case. It’s clear that a majority have spoken.”
Anthony Reese Jr. was sentenced to life without parole for fatally shooting Richard Pittman and April Carbone. Carbone was eight months pregnant with a girl she and Pittman planned to name Layla.