Roommate accused of helping cover up Moorhead teen's killing feared retaliation

Andrea Payne
Andrea Payne
We are part of The Trust Project.

MOORHEAD — The defense attorney for a Moorhead woman is expected to argue she was afraid of what a man accused of killing and dismembering their roommate would do to her if she told authorities the truth.

Andrea Catherine Payne, 27, pleaded not guilty on Wednesday, Sept. 9, in Clay County District Court to two felonies of aiding an offender after the fact in connection with the April death of 19-year-old Dystynee Avery. Court documents allege Payne and others helped 27-year-old Ethan Martin Broad cover up Avery’s death.

Prosecutors have charged Broad with two counts of second-degree murder, alleging he hit Avery over the head with a pipe and threw her dismembered remains in a dumpster on April 3. Avery’s remains were found almost three weeks later at the Clay County landfill. Avery, Payne and Broad were all roommates.

Dystynee Avery.jpg
Dystynee Avery


Payne's attorney, Brian Toay, said he plans to argue that Payne was under duress when she told investigators Avery went missing. Court documents allege she told investigators she didn’t know where Avery was, but that she believed Avery hitchhiked to Colorado or Texas, according to court documents.

Broad was in the room when Payne spoke with officers, and she “was concerned of what would happen if she had told them the truth,” Toay told The Forum in a phone interview.

A criminal complaint claims Payne, who lived with Avery and Broad, was in the apartment but not the same room when she heard her roommates arguing on April 3. She heard “several loud thumps or strikes,” and she left without checking on Avery after Broad told her he “cracked her skull open,” court documents alleged.

Payne later returned — after Broad put Avery's remains in a dumpster — with David Marvin Erno, 22, of Moorhead, according to court documents. She told Erno to grab Avery’s computer and destroy it, the complaint alleged.

Erno, who faces the same charges as Payne and Brandon Everett Leroy Erbstoesser, 33, of Fargo, allegedly wiped the computer clean of its contents, court documents said. Erbstoesser told Broad to report Avery missing and destroy or hide her property, court documents alleged.



Payne is the first defendant in the case to enter a plea. Citing a competency evaluation, Clay County District Judge Michelle Lawson ruled Wednesday that Payne is fit to stand trial.

Toay also plans to file a motion to determine what evidence can be offered if the case goes to trial. He said in court that the prosecution plans to present “disturbing” evidence surrounding the death of Avery.

The prosecution should only be allowed to offer evidence about Payne’s alleged involvement, not about what allegedly happened between Broad and Avery, Toay said.

Clay County Attorney Brian Melton, who is handling prosecution of the case, was out of the office Wednesday and was unavailable for comment.

April Baumgarten joined The Forum in February 2019 as an investigative reporter. She grew up on a ranch 10 miles southeast of Belfield, N.D., where her family raises Hereford cattle. She double majored in communications and history/political science at the University of Jamestown, N.D.
What to read next
A select rundown of stories found on InForum.
Growing the number of Fix It Forward shops helps support the efforts of the Fix It Forward Ministry, a nonprofit that repairs and donates vehicles to people in need, Fix It Forward co-owner Matthew Carlson says.
Follow this Fargo-Moorhead news and weather podcast on Apple, Spotify, and Google Podcasts.
A select rundown of stories found on InForum.