Amid Prohibition, a booze trove discovered in a North Dakota 'cave'

Inside, police found a large room 'filled to the roof with about every kind of intoxicating liquor consumed in this neck of the woods...'

 Destruction of confiscated liquor behind State Capitol, Bismarck (N.D.)
A large crowd observing the destruction of liquor confiscated from a "cave" on Fifth Street in Bismarck, North Dakota, May 17, 1907. Destruction was ordered by Judge Gilbert and carried out under the supervision of Sheriff F. M. Carr.
Courtesy / North Dakota State Archives

BISMARCK — During the early years, Bismarck was right on the heels of Deadwood in lawlessness, violence and the selling of liquor. But, by the early 1900s, some Bismarck residents felt it was time to actually enforce prohibition. Saloons that carried on in secret were called “blind pigs,” and their beverages were either illegally produced locally or brought in from Canada by “runners.”

On April 25, 1907, a Bismarck Tribune headline read: “Thousand Dollars Worth of Booze Found in a Cave,” because Chief Carr found an ‘Unusual Quantity’ of ‘Joyful Water’ under a hill near Fifth Street. He and Temperance Commissioner Murray found a door reinforced with iron bars, so Carr got a shovel and burrowed under it. Inside, they found a 10- by 16-foot room “filled to the roof with about every kind of intoxicating liquor consumed in this neck of the woods...”

A clipping from the Bismarck Daily Tribune, April 25, 1907.
Courtesy / Bismarck Tribune via

Commissioner Murray posted guards, and at dawn they packed the booze into five wagons and took it to the Capitol. The paper reported the cave was “the house of a thousand bottles, to say nothing of the barrels and boxes and cases and jugs and receptacles and containers and vessels and jars and other things in which the juice of the grape and the distillation of the corn is...contained.”

The next day, the paper gave a detailed inventory and reported, “...amid watering mouths and downcast eyes the stuff was taken into vaults and locked up to await the judicial verdict that shall consign it to mother earth, or send it up in vapors to lead the birds to new song and agitate the leaves of the trees with an unwonted glee.”

Some said Kate Richards O’Hare compared soldiers to 'fertilizer.' Others said it never happened; she was just caught in the crossfire of nasty North Dakota politics.
In a way, you could say the carnage dealt out by Old Three Legs wasn’t all his fault, since he had a rough start in life. His mother was a 'freak wolf,' with an evil reputation.
Many details of the case are hazy, but even the known details make the murder case of Agnes Polreis a shocking case of abuse and an example of the power wealth and affluence can have on justice.
A Wisconsin soldier contributed to a historic capture, before moving to Dakota Territory, leaving a legacy for his descendants.
'When prohibition took hold and became law, the Germans from Russia took it personally, and felt they didn’t need to abide by a law forced on them by the Scandinavians of the Valley.'
Dogged persistence led to the discovery of a self-published book by the gang leader of the 1930 Willmar Bank robbery that left one robber dead and three citizens injured.
It was 1937, playing marbles was a big deal, and a state tournament pitted the best of the best against each other. Then came controversy.
The Titanic disaster, which claimed more than 1,500 lives, impacted people the world over. Even North Dakota, far removed from the perils of the ocean, was deeply affected.
Walter Liggett was shot dead while holding a bag of groceries. In part 2 of “The Slaying of Walter Liggett,” why a Minnesota governor and a former North Dakota governor were players in the tragedy.
Walter Liggett was beaten up, framed on rape charges and eventually murdered. In part 1 of this two-part report, Tracy Briggs explores the question: What was he writing about?

Otto Reimer admitted the stock was his and that he stored it there after his saloon was closed. He refused to officially claim it, though; he told officials to do what they wanted with it. So, they opened each container and tested the contents of each to determine “whether or not they were in the nature of an intoxicating liquor.” They were. The judge declared all should be destroyed.


On May 18, 1907, the Tribune reporter waxed poetic — in fact, it sounds like a eulogy:

Not a drum was heard or a funeral note
as the booze to the rampart was hurried;
not a toper fired a farewell shot, o’er the grave
where the bottles were buried.

They burned it swiftly at 2 o’clock,
when the shadows were eastward falling,
and many a mourner near died from shock
at the tragedy so appalling.

Hundreds of bottles of Blatz and Schlitz
that made Milwaukee famous
were flattened and shattered to little bits
when bitterness overcame us.

Barrels of whiskey with heads in caved
were rolled over hill and hollow
and earth, so thirsty was drenched and laved
till no one was left to swallow.

Barrels and bottles and casks and jugs
were opened and gently flowing
a mingled stream of stuff sought the bugs,
and up from the fresh earth blowing
came incense sweet as the breath of morn,
or fields in the Junetime splendid
when loosened spirits of rye and corn
in a perfume sweet were blended.

And Oh but the sight was sweet and sad –
this pouring of free libation
and Oh but the crashing was much and mad,
and would tickle Carrie Nation;
for such is the stuff that is full of woe
and trouble and fret and worry
and such is the cure that the stuff must know –
the cure whose first name is Murray...

“Dakota Datebook” is a radio series from Prairie Public in partnership with the State Historical Society of North Dakota and with funding from Humanities North Dakota. It is edited for presentation on Forum Communication Co. sites by Jeremy Fugleberg, editor of The Vault. See all the Dakota Datebooks at, subscribe to the “Dakota Datebook” podcast, or buy the Dakota Datebook book at

What To Read Next
Get Local