UPDATED: Minnesota bishop resigns at request of pope for covering up sexual abuse by clergy
Minnesota Bishop Michael Hoeppner has resigned at the request of the Pope, the Diocese of Crookston confirmed in a statement Tuesday morning, April 13. The Most Rev. Richard E. Pates, Bishop Emeritus of Des Moines, will serve as Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Crookston until a new bishop is designated.
CROOKSTON, Minn. — Minnesota Bishop Michael Hoeppner has resigned at the request of the pope, the Diocese of Crookston confirmed in a statement Tuesday, April 13.
Hoeppner's resignation followed an extensive investigation into reports that the Diocese covered up reports of sexual abuse by members of the clergy . The investigation, which began in 2019, was the first time a U.S. bishop had been formally investigated under new rules implemented by the pope as the church aimed to standardize the protocol for investigating clergy sexual abuse.
The Forum attempted to reach Hoeppner for comment via diocese officials, but an interview was not granted.
The Most Rev. Richard E. Pates, Bishop Emeritus of Des Moines, will serve as Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Crookston until a new bishop is designated.
Pates' appointment was made public Tuesday when the Diocese of Crookston announced in a statement that Pope Francis had asked for and accepted Hoeppner's resignation.
Pates said Tuesday that one of his main duties will be to welcome parishioners back to in-person worship services as vaccination efforts start to make that possible.
Pates said he learned he would likely be stepping into the role about a month ago, but was unsure of the timeline of the investigation.
Pates arrived in Crookston Monday night, April 12. Although many of his duties will resemble that of the bishop, he is unable to appoint pastors, and clergy members who have been accused of sexual abuse will continue to be probed by a review committee, he said.
Pates, who came out of retirement to take the temporary post in Crookston, said Hoeppner is retiring as well and has plans "to move south" to live with a sister who is also retiring.
Pates said he has a feeling that Tuesday's announcement by the diocese may have come as a relief to some parishioners possibly fatigued by questions that have beset the diocese for some time, though he said there has been no overt expression of that.
He said in coming days and weeks he plans to visit parishes and to make himself available if people want to meet or speak with him.
The Diocese of Crookston includes dozens of churches in Minnesota, including Moorhead, Warroad, Mahnomen and Bemidji.
Lawsuit cast light on issues
Hoeppner was first accused of allowing sexual abuse to continue in a 2017 lawsuit filed in Polk County by Ron Vasek, who says he was sexually abused by Monsignor Roger Grundhaus while on a trip in 1971 when Vasek was 16.
Later, in 2011, when Vasek tried to become a deacon and revealed his abuse, Hoeppner told him to stay quiet, which Vasek believed to be an act of blackmail , according to the lawsuit.
In July 2019, the Diocese of Crookston settled with Vasek and other victims for $5 million. Two months later, the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis announced it would lead the investigation into the alleged coverup following Pope Francis' call for worldwide action.
Vasek said that when he learned of Hoeppner's resignation early Tuesday morning, the news was bittersweet.
"It's too bad that it had to happen, and it's too bad anytime that a bishop resigns because of wrongdoing. But, you know, they are human, and they're sinful men as all of us are," Vasek told the Grand Forks Herald. "But it's a good thing when the truth is revealed, because the truth always overcomes darkness. And that's what's been going on for many, many, many, many years."
Vasek is hopeful that now that justice has been done in his case, it will empower other survivors to come forward.
"I think there's still a lot of healing that needs to happen," he said.
In addition to Vasek's claim, Hoeppner's decision to allow a priest to continue to practice after admitting to sexually abusing a child also was probed.
According to documents released as part of the settlement, Rev. Joseph Richards told a former bishop in 1993 that he had once sexually abused another child when Richards was a teen and had fantasies, while a priest, involving minors. Following the admission, he took a nine-month leave of absence before returning to his ministry duties. He has been a priest at St. Joseph's Church in Fertile, Minn., since 2012.
Hoeppner has publicly defended his decision to allow Richards to continue practicing, though the Diocese placed Richards on a list of clergy members accused of sexual abuse of a minor .
Separate issue sparked billboard pushback
In early 2020, Hoeppner came under fire from some in the Crookston Diocese after the diocese announced it had placed a Bemidji priest on administrative leave following allegations of misconduct that included “boundary violations.”
Father Bryan Kujawa, who formerly served as a priest in Moorhead, was not accused of criminal or sexual misconduct, but his fitness to be a priest was repeatedly called into question, the diocese said.
At the time he was placed on leave, Kujawa said in a statement to parishioners that he attracted scrutiny from the diocese after texting with a minor about spiritual guidance meetings and was placed on suspension after an anonymous woman told the diocese that he had rubbed another woman on her thigh during confession. Kujawa denied that allegation.
The move to place Kujawa on leave was announced as Hoeppner and a group of bishops from Minnesota and the Dakotas met with the pope, according to Catholic News Agency.
Some in the diocese took to placing billboards in support of the priest in some locations in the Fargo-Moorhead and Grand Forks areas.
The billboards read: "Demand Justice for Father Bryan Kujawa."
Tom Morrissey, one of several northern Minnesota Catholics who helped pay for the billboards, said at the time that he wanted fellow members of his faith to ask church leaders in Crookston why they decided to discipline the priest, according to a story in Forum archives.
"I want people to call the diocese and tell them we expect you to explain this. He's convicted and accused of no crime," said Morrissey, who noted at the time that he was not one of Kujawa’s parishioners, but he had met the priest several times.
Diocese statement on resignation
The statement released by the Diocese of Crookston Tuesday reads in full:
"It has been announced today that, after an extensive investigation, the Holy Father, Pope Francis, asked for, and has now accepted the resignation of Bishop Michael Hoeppner from the pastoral governance of the Diocese of Crookston.
"The investigation which led to the acceptance of Bishop Hoeppner’s resignation arose from reports that he had at times failed to observe applicable norms when presented with allegations of sexual abuse involving clergy of the Diocese of Crookston.
"The investigation was conducted pursuant to the motu proprio, Vos estis lux mundi, which had been promulgated by the Holy Father in mid-2019. The investigation was conducted under the supervision of Archbishop Bernard Hebda, the Metropolitan Archbishop of the Province of St. Paul and Minneapolis, which includes the Diocese of Crookston."