SUBSCRIBE NOW Get a year of news PLUS a gift box!



Port: Coal Creek Station's potential terrifies the Sierra Club

Coal Creek Station has the potential to prove that we not only still need coal power, but we can produce coal power cleanly.

Coal Creek Station power plant near Underwood, N.D. Special to The Forum
We are part of The Trust Project.

MINOT, N.D. — Coal Creek Station , the largest coal-fired power plant in North Dakota, has a buyer and the Sierra Club is feeling a little salty about it.

“This smells like a backroom deal that benefits the North Dakota coal lobby, not regular Minnesotans,” Margaret Levin, director of the Minnesota chapter of the Sierra Club, said in a statement posted on the group's website . “It also sounds like Minnesota customers may remain on the hook for paying for power from this economic loser of a plant for years to come.”

Only in the minds of egregious political zealots could the lengthy and well-publicized sale of Coal Creek Station be characterized as a "backroom deal," but I digress.

Levin espouses what is conventional wisdom about coal power in certain political circles.

Coal is dead, these people are wont to say, because it can't compete in the marketplace anymore.


That's true only insofar as the government has propped up coal's competitors like wind and solar with massive subsidies and use mandates.
On an even playing field, one not tilted and manipulated by politicians and ideologues, coal remains a viable and relatively cheap source of baseload power.

In fact, judging by some recent trends in energy now may be a great time to invest in coal power.

Because the government-driven push to "green energy" is showing signs of being a mistake.

Let's consider California, for a moment, the leading state in producing renewable energy . In late June, the state issued yet another "flex alert" asking power customers to reduce their consumption . This perhaps heralds another season of rolling blackouts for that state as energy production fails to keep up with demand.

This is happening even as Californians pay dramatically higher prices for power. Per the Energy Information Administration , the all-sector, per-kilowatt-hour price Californians pay for energy grew by more than 18 cents last year. The state's ratepayers are now doling out 70% more than the average American.

Californians are paying more for power, and getting less, and groups like the Sierra Club would like to bring that unhappy experience to more Americans.


The Sierra Club and their ideological fellow travelers want us to believe that coal is a bad investment, but as energy prices soar and power grids become less reliable because a renewable energy bubble manufactured by the government, a source of energy that is reliable both in production and price, such as a coal power plant, is going to look attractive.

All the more so because Rainbow Energy, Coal Creek Station's buyers, plan to implement carbon capture technology to significantly lower the plant's emissions.

Sen. John Hoeven likes to say North Dakota is "cracking the code" on carbon capture, and he's right.

I can understand why this terrifies the Sierra Club.

Coal Creek Station has the potential to prove that we not only still need coal power, but we can produce coal power cleanly.

To comment on this article, visit

Rob Port, founder of, is a Forum Communications commentator. Reach him on Twitter at @robport or via email at .


Rob Port column sig
Rob Port

Rob Port column sig
Rob Port

Rob Port is a news reporter, columnist, and podcast host for the Forum News Service. He has an extensive background in investigations and public records. He has covered political events in North Dakota and the upper Midwest for two decades. Reach him at Click here to subscribe to his Plain Talk podcast.
What to read next
Minnesota State Moorhead recently hired Chad Markuson as athletic director and Tim Bergstraser as head men's basketball coach.
A lot of people are watching these Republican primaries. North Dakota's government is dominated by Republicans, and there is a pitched battle going on right now for the soul of the NDGOP. These legislative races are the trenches in that battle. So far, based on one of the few objective data points we have, it appears the traditional conservatives are positioned to keep their hold on the party.
An attorney representing North Dakota's coal industry talks about the federal government's efforts to add more clear air regulations on top of the state's already excellent program. Matuor Alier, a candidate for Fargo City Commission, talks about his campaign.
Salonen writes, "Peter Herbeck of Renewal Ministries offered an answer in a video, “Don’t Walk in Darkness,” saying her response reflects society’s abandonment of God and should be a warning.