SUBSCRIBE NOW Get a year of news PLUS a gift box!



Port: Shortages were an inevitable outcome of politicized energy policy

Many, including this humble columnist, have warned that replacing baseload coal-fired power with intermittent wind energy is folly. The mouthpieces for the wind lobby have countered by suggesting coal's demise is just a product of the markets at work and that concerns about grid reliability are nonsense.

Wind Turbines.jpg
We are part of The Trust Project.

MINOT, N.D. — Rarely do things end well when the politicians take it upon themselves to dictate a market's direction.

Once upon a time, about a generation ago, the political class decided that homeownership was a thing worth promoting. They observed that homeowners tended to be prosperous taxpayers and supposed that if they gamed the system so that more people owned homes, we'd have more prosperous people.

The logic was specious. Homeownership is a product of prosperity, not a cause. Still, the argument was a plausible enough veneer for policies that promoted a boom in the housing market and made many people rich.

Banks gave loans to people who couldn't get them before. Homes were built and purchased. For a while, it seemed to be working fine, until suddenly it wasn't. What we got was the subprime mortgage market, a teetering house of cards built on top of loans to people who had no business getting them. When it collapsed, it hurt us all.

Lesson learned?


Not so much.

The wizards of smart in the political class still think they can direct markets with impunity. It's happening in the energy industry, and I'm afraid, as we see headlines about energy shortages and rolling blackouts, the bill is coming due.

For decades, politicians have promoted "green" energy initiatives that focused on punishing energy sources like coal even as sources like wind enjoyed massive subsidies and even mandates for its use. Not surprisingly, this has resulted in closed coal-fired power plants and a booming wind industry.

But when a boom is built on demand driven by subsidies and mandates, is that a good thing?

Many, including this humble columnist, have warned that replacing reliable baseload coal-fired power with intermittent wind energy, or even dependence on the volatile natural gas markets, is folly. The mouthpieces for the wind lobby have countered by suggesting coal's demise is just a product of the markets at work and that concerns about grid reliability are nonsense.

“We don’t have the concern because we know we have both resource adequacy and reliability,” Carlee McLeod, president of Utility Shareholders of North Dakota, told reporters just last week . “We feel these fears at this moment are unfounded.”


All morning I've been getting calls and emails from readers who are losing powers due to rolling blackouts ordered by the Southwest Power Pool, one of the two power grid operators which serve North Dakota.


This is the first time in its history that SPP has had to order blackouts.

The same wind promoters who have told us that grid reliability is not a thing to worry about have also told us that they no longer need the massive subsidies provided by the production tax credit. And yet every year, that subsidy is quietly renewed by Congress.

It's almost as if the wind industry isn't being truthful with us.

Before the collapse of the subprime mortgage market, the politicians and the financial experts told us there was nothing to worry about. Things were fine.

Until they weren't.

The people who supply Americans with energy are in the thrall of politics. They have been making their decisions based less on real-world considerations about what works than on the perverse incentives created by politics. They've been collecting massive subsidies while working to avoid the acrimony of environmental activists. Their duty to provide us with reliable and affordable energy has taken a back seat.


Let's hope this moment in time serves as a wake-up call.

To comment on this article, visit

Rob Port, founder of, is a Forum Communications commentator. Reach him on Twitter at @robport or via email at .

Opinion by Rob Port
Rob Port is a news reporter, columnist, and podcast host for the Forum News Service. He has an extensive background in investigations and public records. He has covered political events in North Dakota and the upper Midwest for two decades. Reach him at Click here to subscribe to his Plain Talk podcast.
What to read next
Tim Mahoney has earned another term as Fargo mayor. Dave Piepkorn has earned another term as Fargo city commissioner and Denise Kolpack is our pick for the open seat on the Fargo City Commission.
Among other extreme stances, far-right candidate calls for imprisonment of political opponent
Our beloved peregrine falcons, those magnificent birds that have called downtown Fargo home for more than 20 years, have lost their nesting platform on the Bell Bank building.
Scott and Ollenburger were front and center in the flopped recall of four board members last year over the district's mask mandate. The recall failed because more than 6,000 petition signatures were deemed invalid, mostly because they were signed by people who didn't live in the Fargo school district. It was a stunning show of incompetence.