NFL: Jalen Hurts is the model 49ers hoped for with Trey Lance

The former North Dakota State quarterback, still nursing an injury that cost him what was to be his breakout season, may watch Hurts in the NFC Championship Game and wonder what might have been.

Trey Lance - NFL: San Francisco 49ers at Chicago Bears
Sep 11, 2022; Chicago, Illinois, USA; San Francisco 49ers quarterback Trey Lance (5) looks to pass in the second quarter against the Chicago Bears at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-USA TODAY Sports
Daniel Bartel/USA TODAY Sports

SANTA CLARA, Calif. — It’s easy to forget that Kyle Shanahan’s vision of his offense going into the season was more similar to that of the Philadelphia Eagles than what he will operate with the 49ers Sunday in the NFC Championship Game.

Give Eagles coach Nick Sirianni credit for instituting a plan and sticking with it in developing Jalen Hurts into a Most Valuable Player candidate. Shanahan, by contrast, adjusted on the fly when Trey Lance was injured and made it to the conference title game for the third time in four years, this time with Brock Purdy, the final pick of the 2022 NFL Draft.

The Eagles are all about Hurts with the ball in his hand, whether he’s cutting upfield on a designed run, headed for greener pastures when his early reads aren’t open or throwing to three dangerous receivers in A.J. Brown, DaVonta Smith and tight end Dallas Goedert.

The 49ers are at their best when Purdy gets the ball out of his hands. When Purdy does go off schedule, he’s not looking to run. Instead, he wants to buy some time until he can find Christian McCaffrey, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle or Brandon Aiyuk.

The 49ers’ plan to go all-in on Lance and his dual-threat ability was scuttled when the second-year quarterback fractured an ankle on an inside run in Week 2 against Seattle.


Lance’s sample size was so small it’s impossible to know how he would have fared. His opening act in Chicago finished in a second-half monsoon and Lance was 13 of 28 for 164 yards with an interception to go along with 13 rushes for 54 yards.

In Week 2, Lance was 2 of 3 for 30 yards and rushed three times for 13 yards before being injured, giving way to Jimmy Garoppolo. Over two games, that’s 15 complete passes and 16 rushes. While the ratio wouldn’t have been as extreme if Lance had remained healthy, it was clear Shanahan had every intention of tweaking his offense with designed runs for his quarterback.

Sirianni began that process with Hurts a year ago, when he carried 139 times for 784 yards and 10 touchdowns as the Eagles went 9-8. This season, Hurts had 165 carries for 760 yards and 13 touchdowns, going 14-1 as a starter. Combined with 3,701 yards, 22 touchdowns and six interceptions passing, Hurts is the likely runner-up to Patrick Mahomes as the NFL’s Most Valuable Player.

Whether Lance could have even approached Hurts’ effectiveness in his first year as a starter is an open question that can never be answered, although it’s easy to be skeptical based on visual evidence.

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (2) scrambles in the third quarter of Sunday's game against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field. Benny Sieu / USA TODAY Sports

Given that Lance was the third player taken in the 2021 NFL Draft and Hurts lasted until the second round at No. 53 overall in 2020, you’d be hard-pressed to find a draft analyst who thought Hurts was the better prospect coming out of college.

Quarterbacks taken before Hurts included Joe Burrow (No. 1 by Cincinnati), Tua Tagovaiola (No. 5 to Miami), Justin Herbert (No. 6 to the Chargers) and Jordan Love (No. 26 to Green Bay).

The Eagles still weren’t sure at the time if Carson Wentz would be their quarterback going forward, with Hurts as an intriguing insurance policy.
Lance, at 6-foot-4 and 225 pounds, is bigger than Hurts, who at 6-foot-1, 223 pounds isn’t all that much different in physical stature than Purdy (6-foot-1, 220). Lance has a bigger arm, which Shanahan planned to use by limiting his options throwing the ball to specific areas while mixing in read options, run-pass options and planned runs.

During training camp as well as early on, there weren’t a lot of Lance highlights other than a 76-yard downfield strike to rookie speedster Danny Gray in the preseason opener against Green Bay on Aug. 12.


It’s fair to wonder whether Lance had enough experience to immediately be a playoff-caliber quarterback and how patient the 49ers would have been in terms of waiting for it to happen. He’d played only 19 games for FCS North Dakota State and played just one game in 2020 because of the pandemic.

Hurts, by contrast, not only played in 56 college games, but played them at Alabama and Oklahoma under Nick Saban and Lincoln Riley. He passed for 9,477 yards with 80 touchdowns and 20 interceptions and rushed for 3,274 yards and 43 touchdowns.

Mature enough to play as a true freshman at Alabama and to stoically handle losing his job to Tagovaiola, Hurts then got a crash course at Riley’s quarterback factory in Oklahoma that has produced Baker Mayfield and Kyler Murray.

NFL: NFC Wild Card Round-Seattle Seahawks at San Francisco 49ers
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13) makes a throw in the second quarter of a wild card game against the Seattle Seahawks on Jan. 14, 2023, at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, Calif.
Cary Edmondson/USA TODAY Sports

Even with all that experience, reviews on Hurts were mixed going into this season until Sirianni saw all the intangible qualities in terms of work ethic and leadership that matched Hurts’ physical skills.

Lance appears to have the same qualities, but the injury was a crucial setback after he was already entering the season with ground to make up in terms of college and NFL playing time.

Shanahan, who already had to recalibrate his offense for Lance, had to revert to the 2021 version with Garoppolo, who performed admirably until he broke his foot on Dec. 4. Purdy’s success has given the 49ers’ offense more diversity with bootlegs and rollouts that weren’t possible with Garoppolo.

It’s clear Purdy’s 47 college starts at Iowa State got him ready to play in a way no one anticipated, much in the same way Hurts benefitted from college snaps. While no one with the 49ers is saying it on the record, Purdy has staked his claim as the starter going forward.

Lance, meanwhile, can look at the opposite sideline Sunday in Philadelphia, watch Jalen Hurts and wonder what might have been.


©2023 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

What To Read Next
Get Local