Trey Lance favored to open '23 as 49ers' starter over Brock Purdy

Purdy avoided Tommy John surgery, which could have shelved him for about a year, but his missing six months makes Lance the odds-on favorite to get the starting nod next season.

San Francisco 49ers quarterback and former NDSU Bison Trey Lance throws during training camp at the SAP Performance Facility in Santa Clara, Calif on July 28.
Stan Szeto / USA Today Sports

The San Francisco 49ers avoided a worst-case scenario with quarterback Brock Purdy, who will have surgery to repair his torn ACL rather than Tommy John surgery.

Rather than being sidelined up to a year, Purdy is expected to miss six months and be ready for training camp.

That still means the last pick in the 2022 draft, who won his first seven starts as a rookie, will miss the team's offseason program. And at least one sportsbook believes that gives former North Dakota State star Trey Lance the inside track to be the 49ers starter to open next season.

Lance is being offered as the -500 favorite by PointsBet to start Week 1 next season ahead of Purdy (+300). The only other player being offered odds on is recently retired Tom Brady at +5000.

Lance, the third overall pick in the 2021 draft, has thrown a total of 102 passes across his first two NFL seasons. That's 68 fewer than Purdy, who was thrust into the starting job midway through his rookie year after Jimmy Garoppolo suffered a foot injury in Week 13.


Garoppolo was filling in for Lance, who suffered a season-ending broken ankle in Week 2.

Now it's Lance who finds himself as the focal point of the 49ers' offseason, with coach Kyle Shanahan saying last week that he doesn't see a scenario in which the team brings Garoppolo back. The sportsbook isn't even offering odds on Garoppolo opening next season under center for San Francisco.

Lance, who declared for the NFL draft after North Dakota State moved its COVID-delayed 2020 season to the following spring, has played eight football games in the past three years. That includes going 2-2 as a starter for the 49ers while completing just 54.9 percent of his career NFL passes with five touchdowns and three interceptions.

It's an incredibly small sample size for a team coming off a run to the NFC Championship on the shoulders of their third-string quarterback from training camp.

That's why many believe the job should be Purdy's -- if "Mr. Irrelevant" from last year's draft is healthy. That includes the best quarterback in franchise history.

"If Purdy's healthy I think it's his job," Joe Montana said Wednesday, per

Lance will receive the bulk of the reps with the first team during the offseason program, but Montana believes his overall body of work remains too small to be trusted at the helm of a Super Bowl-caliber offense.

"I don't think he's ready yet," Montana said. "I don't think he's ready to take that caliber team. Talented kid, and he might be, part way through the year if he gets more starts.


"I don't know, but do you want to turn over a team that you want to get off to a great start with a guy you still have a question about?"


This story was written by one of our partner news agencies. Forum Communications Company uses content from agencies such as Reuters, Kaiser Health News, Tribune News Service and others to provide a wider range of news to our readers. Learn more about the news services FCC uses here.

Field Level Media is a partner news agency for Forum Communications Company.
What To Read Next
Get Local